Reader Reviews for this Book
Review posted April 24, 2021
This book focuses on Native Americans, not Native North Americans, which is fine, I am just so used to hearing only about North American Indians that I was surprised. I really like the way the chapters in the book address varies factors of influence. Most I find fascinating and I have learned a lot. It easy and interesting to read, not a dull text book read at all. I highly recommend if you would like to learn more about the origins of many different aspects of life as we know it now. In fact, as I read I keep thinking of people I want to share this book with.
Review posted April 7, 2021
My mom really enjoyed this book and the history it talked about.
Review posted March 31, 2021
good information, biased presentation Some of the points weren't really about what NA had to offer at all, but things incidental to the continents that literally anyone who lived there would have discovered. Overall there is a lot of interesting information, interestingly presented. Think of it as a guilty pleasure side-dish to a real history book.
Review posted March 31, 2021
This was a very interesting read, I found it gave me another perspective. I would recomind this to others
Review posted March 25, 2021
This was an easy reading book that had a lot of very interesting information. I learned a lot.
Review posted March 22, 2021
This book is very well written and I would definitely recommend.
Review posted March 19, 2021
I found this book facinating. Some of the historical connections between Native American tribal communities and practices and our current governmental structure and other parts of daily life were new to me. While it seems in the first few chapters as if perhaps the information doesn't apply to North American, the author does an excellent job of weaving all the information into a network of worldwide influence by Native Americans. This is a reprint of an older book, so some of language may not be considered politically up to date by everyone, but please look past that and really try to wrap your head around the depth of detail that is included.
Review posted March 15, 2021
Although Mr. Weatherford is/was an Anthropologist, he writes as if he is a layman. I was not impressed by his massive leaps in (or around) logic. This book seems to still be written from a white, colonial perspective even though he does give credit to indigenous peoples for many things. His conclusion chapter was almost leaning toward racism. I think a better read would be 'The FIrst Oregonians' or something of that ilk.
Review posted March 5, 2021
This book was very enlightening as to the influence of our Native forefathers and their contributions to the white man society who came and stole their lands. A recommended read for anyone interested in history
Review posted February 22, 2021
You will learn about little known contributions of Native Americans not only to American culture and history, but to world civilization. While the writing in some of the 14 essays that make up this book are written better than others, my favorite was the essay on their contributions to medicine. Who knew? We should have learned these things in school.
Review posted February 9, 2021
Amazingly informative book, I wish all people could read and understand the message.
Review posted February 2, 2021
Learned or more contributions American Indians gave not only to the us but to the entire word.
Review posted January 12, 2021
This is a good look at how tribal history has had rippling effects throughout our society. I work in a tribal childcare setting and I found this book an enjoyable read.
Review posted December 7, 2020
Some interesting history, but was saddened by how the book centered whiteness rather than indigenous history.
Review posted December 3, 2020
A great look at Native American history, especially in the U.S. It felt like a behind the scenes of what they don't teach you in school textbooks. I look forward to reading more on our Native American population specific to the PNW region.
Review posted December 2, 2020
So much untold history.
Review posted November 10, 2020
A great (re)membering of Native and settler contact within Turtle Island.
Review posted October 30, 2020
Review posted October 16, 2020
I think this is a book all Americans should read. Our nations treatment of Native Americans was hideous and immoral. As with African Americans, the horrible truth is glossed over in history classes and popular culture. This book is very enlightening and makes this obvious.
Review posted October 16, 2020
This book offered a great perspective and content. It was a great way to expand on what is traditionally lacking in our school system ciriculumn.
Review posted September 26, 2020
Jack Weatherford does a great job of sharing the many ways that Native Americans have contributed to culture and society. So many facts and things I never knew or had even thought about. Great information. The stories laced throughout the chapters help make it a more enjoyable and easier read.
Review posted August 25, 2020
I believe this book should be a part of childhood school curriculum and even part of the history courses in college. The title is a bit misleading making it like they took something away (the old derogatory saying from long ago childhood): however, it's actual meaning is how much Indians gave Americans especially in crop technology. This book is an eye opener and I highly recommend.
Review posted July 21, 2020
This book wildly open my eyes to the contributions of the native people of Americas have brought to the world. The exploitation of their labor to strip their land of their natural resources in support of lands and societies far away was just heartbreaking. Thank you for sharing this title. Can’t wait to pass along to a friendly share the wealth.
Review posted July 10, 2020
The author, Jack Weatherford, connects the historical dots in ways that are sometimes obvious and other times profoundly amazing. The American Indians supplied the knowledge to create world economies, food to change the historical famines in Europe, and a new political system based on merit and not blood lines. Once he explains it, it becomes so obvious that even a newbie can understand this flow of history.
Review posted June 30, 2020
INDIAN GIVERS By Jack Weatherford will be an eye-opener to someone like me, a fifth generation Irish-German immigrant. Although I have lived around Native Americans most of my life and have always had a great deal of empathy for them because of what some of my ancestors inflicted on their ancestors. A terrible travesty. Reading the book made me more humble and thankful to our Native American brothers and sisters than ever. Growing up in a white community with a Reservation nearby as a kid an Indian Giver was known as someone who gave you something and then asked for it back later. Jack Weatherford’s title INDIAN GIVER caught my eye for the definition I’d known of the word. I surprised in reading nearly every page of his book I learned something I didn’t know that the Indians of the America’s gave to us — the invaders of their homeland. Silver and gold for an economic system. Agriculture crops never seen in the Old World potatoes, corn, quinoa, and many techniques to grow these and an incredible amount more! One of the most impressive gifts the Indians of the America’s gave the Old World was an understanding of new drugs that would become the birth of the pharmacological industry today. Coca from the Andes eventually become cocaine refined to many local anesthesia. Tobacco grown right where the Pilgrims landed on the east coast of the United States eventually made a huge impact financial on exports. Overall, INDIAN GIVERS was a educational, informative and easy read that I enjoyed. I’m no scholar however the explanation of history of the people’s and places described in his book makes it easy for the layperson to understand. Great Book!
Review posted June 29, 2020
Great Book I never realized the contribution The American Indian both North & South had on my world today.
Review posted April 3, 2020
This is a fascinating book that was both interesting and enjoyable to read. It was a relatively easy read even with it being well researched with notes. I highly recommend it. The scope of the influence of Native Americans culture is huge.
Review posted March 17, 2020
Review posted March 11, 2020
I really appreciate the title's play on words and how educational the book was. It was not difficult to read and emphasized how innovative and important this very marginalized community is. Definitely recommend this book.
Review posted February 25, 2020
Indian Givers isn't casual 'lite reading'...it's for those who desire the 'journey' more than the 'destiny'. Indian Givers is a journey filled with spectacular details that traditional 'Native American' books leave out. Enjoy the Journey
Review posted February 22, 2020
Very informative and helpful in improving my understanding of Native American history
Review posted February 19, 2020
Jack Weatherford book "Indian Givers" is filled full of facts and credits the people of the Americas with many things that have been hidden through the colonial lens. Unfortunately I found the voice of the book to be very much from the dominant cultural perspective.
Review posted February 16, 2020
Excellent summation of everything that we, as non-natives in the Americas, have gotten (taken) from the indigenous peoples who lived here long before we came to these shores. I had no idea of the huge amount that these peoples had contributed to our political organization, our medicines, our foods, and how they had contributed to the rise of capitalism through the european exploitation of them in the new world mines. Mind-blowing at the very least. We currently talk of reparations for the european exploitation of black Africans, but it seems that we owe at least as much, and maybe a whole lot more, to the Native Americans that we did much worse to, and tried to wholesale kill off on our way to stealing pretty much everything they had, before the europeans arrived to exploit them.
Review posted February 15, 2020
What does it mean to rethink how Native Americans transformed, not one country or region - the world? Life-shifting. Indian Givers, by Jack Weatherford is that book. Learning means you're willing to be open to thinking you may be unaware of and may not necessarily want to read or learn. Read this book if you're sincerely curious and willing to take in information about how our world has been impacted by cultures well beyond the 'modern world'. Highly recommend.
Review posted January 27, 2020
Decent insight on the gifts provided to us by the Native American Culture
Review posted December 15, 2019
There were many points on which the governmental establishments discussed in the book sound remarkably alike to the Trauma Informed movement happening in the mental health field. I also especially enjoyed the biomedical and medicinal anecdotes. I recommended this book to a few friends who have interests across broad fields as this book is written.
Review posted November 30, 2019
I really enjoyed the book Indian Givers by Jack Weatherford. I have always had an interest in Native Americans but being an immigrant to the USA I did not know very much about them. This book has been a revelation and made me see the indigenous peoples of the Americas in a new light. From money to food, medicine, architecture and much more, they have contributed an enormous amount to Europe and other parts of the world. The book is well written and easy to read and I recommend it to anyone wanting to increase their knowledge of a group of people who have contributed so much to the world
Review posted November 16, 2019
Got this book for mom. Her side of the family is Indian. It has been a great read for her. Learned quite a few things about the history of the Indians. Thank you
Review posted November 5, 2019
A great book for looking at history through a different lens. Discusses many different Indigenous peoples, not just the American Indian.
Review posted October 25, 2019
This one was challenging for me to get into. I want to come back and try again in a few months when I might have more time to focus.
Review posted October 21, 2019
This was a nice read, easily browsed a chapter or two at a time. There were parts with annoyingly sweeping generalizations about "the Indians," but once the introductory paragraphs of a chapter were through it got into satisfying specifics about how much native North and South American cultures have contributed to our current modern world.
Review posted October 21, 2019
this book was interesting but hard to read.
Review posted October 8, 2019
This book was engaging and informative. It was an easy read that I thoroughly enjoyed. I recommend this book to anyone interested in history, traditional ecological knowledge, or any non-fiction book where you want to learn. So full of info and interesting that I will read this one again.
Review posted September 28, 2019
I learned so much from this book! The combination of the books Lies My Teachers Told Me, There There, and Indian Givers have given me a profound appreciation for the Native American culture. What an incredible group of individuals. They have absolutely impacted our world in such positive ways. Thank you Select Books!
Review posted September 18, 2019
Well written, and much needed history: how Bolivian silver promoted individual liberty, tales of potatoes and tomatoes, diplomacy that impressed Benjamin Franklin, and even more. I will pass this book on to others! Easy, short read as well.
Review posted September 5, 2019
Great book, from a great writer. This author writes from a different angle. Very interesting.
Review posted August 27, 2019
An engaging and thorough presentation of Native Americans' impact on the cultural formation of North America. Provides a more complete and diverse history of our formation as a nation.
Review posted August 27, 2019
Very interesting historical accounts that bring to light the stories of greed, prejudice, exploitation, and deaths of so many.
Review posted August 19, 2019
Weatherford does an excellent job bringing history to life and explaining how much of our world today was created due to what we learned 500 years ago from native Americans. Exploring issues such as our government structure. Home remedies when it comes to treating as medicine, etc.
Review posted August 9, 2019
This was a great book. Loved it!
Review posted August 2, 2019
This is a book I will keep on my shelf. Reading this confirms the truth that we truly are "one world." The food and crop contributions from the New World to the Old World are pretty well known (potatoes, tomatoes, corn, tobacco) but some of the other Native American contributions are less well known, such as how the gold and silver extracted from the New World and sent to Europe enabled a money system with standardized values and a true world economy. The story is deep and the book detailed. Since each chapter covers a different subject it is not necessary to read the whole thing page by page. But it is a book I expect to refer back to time and time again.
Review posted July 30, 2019
I loved how this book shared many native peoples contributions to our modern world! I think it is a well written history of how miss treated and unappreciated an entire people have been and how thankful we should be that they shared their knowledge with the world.
Review posted July 25, 2019
The author, Jack Weatherford, has an almost unique ability to find connections between causes and effects. This book follows up on his earlier book "Indian Givers" that explains the many aspects of our dominant (Anglo) culture that are borrowed, at least in part, from Native culture. The book is ultimately a good reminder that we who are not Indigenous to this continent took this land from those that were. We owe Native people much more than they have received.
Review posted July 15, 2019
I wish Indian Givers were in every middle and high school classroom - and assigned reading! Organized with "partnered" chapters, one providing history and the second detailing outcomes, it provides a strong foundation for discussion and reflection.
Review posted July 11, 2019
Indian Givers was a good historical overview of the ways that Native peoples from all over the Americas have greatly influenced the current culture and society, where they are usually not given that credit. It was very informative to see how food, agriculture, architecture, governing, and other aspects of Western life have been shaped by those that were here on this land well before us.
Review posted July 11, 2019
"Indian Givers" is a well written book with interesting present day narratives at the beginning of each chapter that relate back to the chapters subject. The author does a good job of giving the reader a glimpse into the history of how some modern practices came to be. Great book for anyone interested in history.
Review posted July 1, 2019
I was not sure what to expect from this book. However it was very interesting. I work for tribal, so this was a great insight.
Review posted June 26, 2019
When i was growing up we visited Minnesota and loved to watch the "indian" dances, listen to their stories, and watch them deftly harvest wild rice. I did not know at that time the impact they had on our history. The title of the story first has a negative connotation but the information inside is informative and fascinating. I enjoyed this book immensely.
Review posted May 29, 2019
This book was cooler than I expected. I'm still ruminating on the agricultural influence of Native Americans. It seems likely that the world would be very different without potatoes, tomatoes, beans, and guano. This is the Native American history that is missing in our schools and in our relationships with others.
Review posted May 26, 2019
Overall, Indian Givers was a good book and seemingly well researched. Some of it drags, but some chapters read well. He gives many examples of the contributions of food, medicine, and philosophy that have contributed to world culture, but sometimes fails to acknowledge the parallels that developed in the rest of the world. For example, Mr. Weatherford extols the design and construction of the Inca roads, but fails to recognize that the Romans created an equally intricate paved road system much earlier. Ingenuity is world-wide, but is geared towards the problems at hand. All in all, I recommend "Indian Givers" as a good book to read, consider, and draw your own conclusion.
Review posted May 8, 2019
I have to admit, I thought Indian Givers was going to be a dry intellectual discourse about the impact that indigenous tribes have made on the world. I was completely surprised when reading this book by Jack Weatherford. The information was shared in a very readable prose style, which allows the reader to engage both the rational and creative aspects of his writing. I recommend this as a book that gives a insightful perspective on how the world is made better because of Native Americans and their creative, innovative and spiritual culture.
Review posted May 7, 2019
interesting book. Gives you a different perspective..things you never realized there is another side
Review posted May 7, 2019
I found generally interesting information in this book mostly about the agriculture of the Americas. Had hoped that the book would focus more on US Indian culture as it relates to us today. Felt the book was hard to read as it jumped through time for each subject, would have preferred more chronological picture of the total contribution to our modern uses of the past knowledge of the Indian practices.
Review posted April 30, 2019
This was a fascinating read. I found it to be a bit of a slow start, but the chapters on healing, food, and drugs were especially interesting and enlightening. My eyes were opened!
Review posted April 23, 2019
This is an amazing book, that traces some of our common terms as well as many of our democracy's' roots. Very easy read, and enlightening.
Review posted April 22, 2019
There is a lot of history in this book. I thought it would be more about Native American history but feel that the book digresses into much more.
Review posted April 17, 2019
“The discovery of America sparked a revolution in food and cuisine that has not yet shown any signs of abating.” I received this book from the Ford Family Foundation for free as long as I was willing to review it. I am happily fulfilling my obligation. This is the story of the many benefits the world received when they discovered America. I think we all know about the many foods like tomatoes, avocadoes and pecans they gave us. How many of us know about the medicinal contributions like aspirin, or growing vegetable benefits like putting in fish heads along with the seed when planting? My favorite new thing I learned was that our government and constitution contain many items that the Native Indians used in their confederacies, including one man, one vote. Ben Franklin was a student of their governing style when he was in charge of the Indians in his district. He brought a lot of their ideas to include in our constitution. This was a fascinating history of the many benefits we gained from the native tribes that lived in the Americas. I think it is about time they got their due.
Review posted April 12, 2019
This book holds a wealth of historical and socio-cultural information about how indigenous people have shaped our food industry, pharmaceutical industry and retail industrial. It was nice to know where words such as "jerky" and "BBQ" came from. I highly recommend this book for anyone how loves history and culture. With any accurate recount of Native Americans and Indigenous people, there are graphic recounts of the realities of colonization, war and slavery.
Review posted April 8, 2019
Not quite what I was expecting, but still a good read.
Review posted April 2, 2019
At first I balked a bit at the title of this book, as “Indian giver” is an offensive term to Native Americans. But it’s a well-written piece, that dives deep in a number of areas about Native American history and culture — and how they have influenced the country we know today. It is worth the read.
Review posted February 10, 2019
Super informative, but kinda boring.
Review posted January 9, 2019
I thought this book was great. Very accessibly written, provides a lot of interesting information. Each chapter covers a different topic, such as agriculture, architecture, medicine, etc. and outlines the huge contributions made by indigenous peoples of the Americas. Personally the story i found most interesting was about the Creek people of the southeast US and how their leader successfully held off incursions by the British, French, Americans & Spanish around them by playing them off against each other, and then the cultural movement that arose (called the Red Sticks) after that leader died.
Review posted December 20, 2018
This book was initially difficult for me to "get into," perhaps because it began with financial activities. However, it was ultimately fascinating the areas of our current world we owe thanks for to Native Americans.
Review posted December 15, 2018
I got this book intending to give it away when I was finished to an aunt. After reading it I got my aunt her own because it was too good. It reminded me of the book Freakonomics by Stephen Dubner and Steven Levitt with the way it was written. I learned a great deal about ingeniousness people across the globe.
Review posted December 2, 2018
Well put together. I enjoyed reading this very much as I do all of the publications offered by the Ford Family Foundation. Thank you William Schmidt
Review posted November 20, 2018
I was so thankful to add this book to my collection on Native American culture and sociology. I myself am a Modoc Native of Klamath Falls. I have known for a long time just how great the native Americans were. But I didn’t know exactly how much they changed European culture itself. 5 stars!
Review posted November 9, 2018
This is a very informative book, not a leisurely book, very educational
Review posted November 2, 2018
Review posted November 2, 2018
I enjoyed reading about the origin of so many everyday things, especially the foods we currently enjoy. Who knew that America contributed so generously to the cuisine enjoyed throughout the whole world? I suppose, because of the beautiful illustration on the cover, I was expecting the book to focus more on the Indians who live in the United States. instead, it seemed to be more about the history of the people south of the US. I learned a lot about the metal mining and how the other established countries of the world ransacked the Americas and killed the inhabitants, either through murder or by making slave laborers out of them. If you enjoy reading about the origin of modern life, you'll like this book.
Review posted October 30, 2018
Review posted October 22, 2018
This book was an interesting read. Well covered about Indians and history of our early natives.
Review posted October 15, 2018
REALLY learned a lot from this book -- especially the discussion of urban planning, and the author's thoughts on democracy as an Indian concept.
Review posted October 1, 2018
Really useful book
Review posted September 20, 2018
I really enjoyed and appreciated reading this book. My knowledge on the Native American history was minor compared to what this book offered me. I have a much better understanding of the culture especially relating to the farming/land use, medical and governance structure.
Review posted September 14, 2018
I found book "Indian Givers" to be both thoughtful and entertaining. The author manages to keep the reader engaged while sometimes discussing sensitive material. It wasn't a book I would normally choose for myself to read, but I'm very glad that I chose to pick it up!
Review posted September 3, 2018
Jack Weatherford is truly a master of his craft and is a premier historian and anthropologist. This work is just as compelling as his Genghis Khan book, as it is well researched and professionally stated. Weatherford embraces Native American culture and ties that culture into the frame of the larger world. Native American culture has had a significant impact on the formation of American cultural, social, and political practices. Weatherford certainly provides a credit to that historical fact.
Review posted August 22, 2018
Good read, good information
Review posted August 12, 2018
Review posted August 2, 2018
This a an amazingly insightful look at a very whitewashed part of the story of the Americas. I
Review posted July 22, 2018
This was an eye-opening perspective on how the Native American culture shaped our world.
Review posted July 20, 2018
Review posted July 11, 2018
I loved this book and would highly recommend it to anyone who is interested in Native Americans and what they have contributed to this country.
Review posted June 20, 2018
Indian Givers was a great read. As a Native American myself, the title intrigued me as well as made me wonder as "Indian Giver" generally has a negative stigma attached to it, but all in all it was super informative and I learned a lot
Review posted June 6, 2018
This book is an excellent read about the great contributions of the native peoples of America to modern American culture. It offers a perspective of history that is often obscured--if not utterly neglected--in our parochial educational system.
Review posted May 31, 2018
So much knowledge stuffed into the pages. It is Well written, yet a bit hard handling the volume of detail. Specifically naming every Mountain, near City, roads and rivers close by. Do not let the names and lack of pronunciations deter you. It is engrossing and an overall pleasure.
Review posted May 21, 2018
This book is a very thorough journey through Indian history. At times, a bit too informative but informative non the least. I was expecting more of a novel.